Are Baseball and Softball Cleats The Same?

Are baseball and softball cleats the same? It’s a common enough question. And for such an important piece of equipment, it definitely needs an answer.

While baseball and softball are similar enough, there are differences between baseball cleats vs softball cleats.


baseball vs softball cleats

What’s the Difference between Baseball and Softball Cleats?

While the main difference between baseball and softball cleats used to be that softball did not allow metal cleats, that has now changed. Now the main difference is in the shape of the spikes. Softball cleats have rules about the shape of the spikes while baseball cleats do not have the same regulations.

Baseball vs Softball Cleats Material

As of 2010, metal cleats are allowed in softball and baseball. There is one difference though:

In softball, the spikes must be rectangular – they can’t be round.

In baseball, the spikes on the bottom of the cleat can be any shape. In both sports, spikes cannot be longer than 3/4 inches.


One thing to consider if you’re thinking about buying baseball cleats as a softball player is the toebox. The toebox is the amount of space available for your toes.

Because baseball cleats are primarily designed for men, they tend to have a wider toebox. Many softball players find that the toebox is too wide for them to be comfortable in baseball cleats.

This is why we still recommend buying softball cleats if you’re playing softball and baseball cleats if you’re playing baseball.

Width and Sizes

Again, as baseball cleats are designed for men, they’ll primarily come in men’s sizes and men’s widths. If you’re a softball player who wants a baseball cleat, be sure to take this into account.

Generally order a size smaller and a little narrower cleat than you normally would. This will ensure you find one of the best baseball cleats for you and one that’s comfortable enough to stand in for multiple seasons.

Can Softball players wear baseball cleats?

For the most part, yes softball players can wear baseball cleats. You have to consider appropriate sizing, the position you play, and league rules however, before you step out onto the field.

League Rules

Softball allows metal cleats but the spikes have to be rectangular and can’t be more than 3/4 inch in length. As long as you follow those rules, you should be able to play with baseball cleats.

Appropriate Sizing

As most baseball cleats are designed for boys, be sure to order a size down than your regular softball cleat size. Also, be sure to consider the fit of the cleat. Most baseball cleats will be wider than the softball cleat equivalent. Consider ordering a narrower cleat to ensure comfort.


Depending on your particular position, you may want to go with softball cleats versus baseball cleats. Softball pitchers, for example, tend to have a different movement pattern than baseball pitchers.

 Baseball Cleat Sizing for Softball Players

What size baseball cleat should you get if you’re a softball player? Check out our chart below.

Baseball And Softball Cleats Size By Shoe Brands

Baseball & Softball Cleats Size Chart By Brands


Are softball shoes and baseball shoes the same thing

Yes, while baseball cleats are designed for men and softball cleats are designed for women, they are primarily the same thing.

Baseball Cleats vs Softball Cleats Similarities

Some of the critical similarities include:

  • The shoes have a similar cleat pattern, which is different from other sports such as football.
  • They have similar sizes, and the player may either select lower or higher boot depending on their ankle strength.

Baseball Cleats vs Softball Cleats Differences

Some of the factors that make it hard to use baseball shoes in softball games (and vice versa) include:

  • The baseball shoes are highly customizable for specific playing positions. Softball shoes, on the other hand, have less distinction between positions.
  • Softball as a sport has a more liberal approach to sports shoes compared to baseball. While you can play with any shoe in softball games, you cannot play with softball shoes in most baseball competitions.

Types of Baseball and Softball Cleats

The main distinction between these two sports and other sports is the freedom to use different cleats. The liberty has therefore attracted different cleats manufacturers and more importantly, the options have made this niche home to innovations.

Softball and baseball have a set of cleats that are ideal for training and tournaments (or both).

Types of Baseball Cleats

If you are a baseball player or you are planning to start playing the sport, you should consider shoes first. Baseball shoes have evolved in the past century. Currently, these are the best cleats for baseball players.

Metal Cleats

Metal cleats are, without a doubt the best option for professional players and those wishing to transit to professional baseball leagues. Metal baseball cleats give the best grip on the baseball diamond while still allowing you to move quickly around the field.

Baseball metal cleats - ibatreviews

Molded Cleats

If you are a young professional player looking for an alternative cleat that is safe to play on, molded cleats are the best option. These cleats are durable and provide the best support.Baseball Molded cleats

Interchangeable Baseball cleats

Interchangeable cleats are, without a doubt, the most versatile cleats option. They are ideal for younger leagues if you use molded options and professional leagues if you use metal or molded fittings.

Interchangeable Baseball cleats

Types of Softball Cleats

If you are interested in playing softball, or you are already a player looking for cleats, here are some of the suggestions to consider.

Molded Softball  cleats

Molded softball cleats are popular in the world of softball, thanks to their durability and shape. A pair of shoes can easily last a season. These cleats are also safe from slides and common technical errors in softball.Molded Softball cleats

Turf  Softball cleat

When it comes to comfort during softball training sessions and tournaments, turf cleats are unmatched. Although they don’t offer the ideal grip, they are suitable for youth leagues and professional softball players looking for comfortable options.



High Baseball Cleats vs Low Softball Cleats

Generally, if you want a high top option, you have to go with a baseball cleat instead of a softball cleat. High top baseball cleats tend to provide more protection against ankle injuries when compared to other options.


Do you have ankle injuries? If you have some injuries and you wish to continue playing baseball or softball, it is advisable to go with high cleats. The high cleats give you the needed support and therefore, they are the safer option.


Do you want to play in comfortable shoes? Although comfort can be subjective, generally lower cleats are more comfortable than high top cleats. Your ankle is less restricted as you move around and there is more space for joint flexibility.

Your position

Which position do you play in baseball or softball? If you play in a position that requires more speed, you may take low cleats for maximum speed. On the other hand, the high cleats may be ideal in positions that may subject your ankle to strains.

Leave a Comment